Good intentions hit car industry

Monday 24th November 2008, 8:29AM GMT.

The motor industry has been thrown into chaos by the stupid governments of this world.

Jobs in vehicle production and small industries have been put into jeopardy because of decisions made in haste by governments keen on getting on the green bandwagon.

The decision to reduce the amount of emissions from vehicles is commendable, but it should be noted that when motor vehicle producers tooled up for production 10 years ago or more, the criteria were much different.

Seemingly overnight the large vehicles have been outlawed with the introduction of higher taxes and the stigma of the gas-guzzling eco-unfriendly motorist, although a lot of the large vehicles are very fuel efficient.

Surely it would have been better to tell the motoring manufacturers that in 10 years a new standard of vehicle size and emission would be introduced worldwide.

This would have allowed the stocks of vehicles that have already used power and materials in their production to be used instead of sitting and rotting on acres of land. Isn’t it more eco-friendly to use what you already have?

Give fair and clear notification to manufacturers to design new, more energy-efficient vehicles, running on alternative fuels, but give them time to re-tool their factories.

Ten years in the earth’s evolution isn’t even a blink of an eye.

If this ill thought-out rush by governments into green issues is allowed to continue, the future problems for the economy and employment will be catastrophic, and only prolong the crisis in which we find ourselves.

D G Lavill, School Lane, Bushbury.


  1. 1
    chris

    I don’t think it would have made a whole lot of difference anyway. It’s only been the last few years that the governments have really took the environment issues seriously. I don’t think that even now its a main priority because of the financial gain being made from oil. It seems they do just enough to appease the general populous. The worst polluting vehicles are probably buses and lorries as they run on diesel, but there no real legislation against these forms of transport,and yet the government wants evryone to ditch their cars and use these forms of transport. I thought we were producing cleaner cars, and if so this seems to be a bit backwards.

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    Martin Davies

    Tooling? What happened to just producing vehicles that are efficient?
    Funny really, a Rolls is quite a bit more luxurious than a Ford Ka, yet the KA is far, far more economical.
    Has anyone had a go about the Rolls? No, they have a go about 4x4s.

    The manufacturers have known for many years about how green things need to be. How long does it take to get the tooling done? New cars are designed, new tooling done, still bad emissions.

    Yet people still want to drive cars, regardless of emissions. Far more convenient than other forms of transport much of the time.

    The car industry is affected by governments. And who do they turn to when they need help? The government.
    The car industry also responds to consumer demand. Where has that lead us? Better cars – generally not brilliantly efficient though.

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    CHRIS

    Actually most cars are efficient. Unfortunately it’s man that is inefficient expecting to sort out any green issues by constantly charging money for it.

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    North Carolina Wolf

    Well said CHRIS – this pursuit of “green” – whatever it is – will never be over as long as there is financial and political gain to be made from it. Since 1990 when I believe the use of Catalytic Converters was made mandatory in the UK, cars have by definition been “cleaner” and presumably, therefore, “greener”. Similarly, advancements in technology and manufacturing processes and changes in emissions legislation – have led to manufacturing and product efficiencies which Companies have had to adopt in order to stay competitive, compy with the law and attract and retain shareholder interest. However, it suits, and will always suit, the government of the day to regard the vehicles of the day to be just as inefficient and polluting as they were 20/30/40 years ago, as to them, the motorist is an endless source of untapped wealth and oppotunity for mass mind-control and ripe for continual persecution.

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    Martin Davies

    Not sure I’d class most cars as efficient.
    How many do under 25mpg? Quite a number, in road tests rather than manufacturer tests.

    Still quite a bit more efficient than tanks, motor cruisers, planes and loaded HGVs.

    The car is seen as a moneymaker by government because it is. Few of us will get rid of the car just because fuel, insurance or road tax have gone up.
    Too convenient to run one. So we pay, and pay, and pay.
    And they rake the money in which allows them to avoid adding a load more onto income tax.

    Report abuse

  6. 6
    Al

    The EU set voluntary emission standards at the end of the 90′s (after long discussions with car makers). About 2005, they set mandatory standards due to the lack of progress by the car companies (mostly the German ones – French and Italians were quite good).

    So it’s hardly as though any of this was a surprise to the car makers and their own (lack of)actions condemned them to the current situation

    Report abuse

  7. 7
    woolibuga

    You are all missing the one most important point!………….. “Volume”

    I was born in a Britain when Car ownership for the masses was to all intents and purposes Zero! ……… even into my teens and my bike was my magic carpet I could on the weekend ride for three hours before I even saw a Motor Vehicle ……… take a look at this Sceptred Isle today …. it is awash with motor vehicles .. you have even invented a weird name to describe some of it “TailBack”……. it does not matter how efficient you make the “Great God Ka” sheer numbers will ensure you retain the concern for the environment and you will fight to place your offerings on its Alter.

    What is needed is not a more efficient car but a more efficient way of moving people …… next time you are about make note of how many of these icons of peoples modern desire are carrying one person! ………………

    Report abuse

  8. 8
    Rebecca

    More than a more efficient way of moving people, woolibuga, how about people just live closer to where they work, or work closer to where they live? Instead, people think it’s their right to be able to work in Birmingham city centre and live in Kinver or Knowle, and then complain about congestion and fuel prices…

    Report abuse

  9. 9
    CHRIS

    How can people always live closer to where they work or visa versa? Surely you have to go where the work is. Rebecca your comments are little bit thin on the ground.

    Report abuse

  10. 10
    woolibuga

    Rebecca! …….. There are those that Cannot See! … and those that Will Not See! …… it’s a No Brainer! ….. if you put one person twixt four wheels and a ton of plastic and metal and multiply this concoction by many millions of times and then allow him/her to try and navigate already jampacked paved roads then you are inviting a recipe for frustration and ultimately disaster.

    Of course people will want to live in a place of there choosing and commute to a place of work ……. your illustration of example of a City Centre as a place of work is already being done in much larger Cities than Birmingham … millions travel daily from the City Centre of London to the suburbs by Underground and Rail ……… over a Century ago Britain had a rail infrastructure that was the envy of the world …. and why shoudn’t it be! …. they invented it! ……… until the “The Great God Ka” usurped it’s importance and caused it’s shortsighted decline ……. well re-invent it and with 21st century technology it could be just that again ….. the envy of the world! …….. and bear in mind it costs a heck of a lot less to build a mile of railway than it does to build a mile of road!………

    Report abuse

  11. 11
    Martin Davies

    Chris, people can move closer to where they work. Or work closer to home if they can find a job close by.

    Instead, for whatever reason, people put up with travelling sometimes hundreds of miles a week back and forth to work.
    Decades ago it was accepted that most people would live within walking or bus distance from work. These days it can be a couple of hours drive each way for some…..

    Report abuse

  12. 12
    CHRIS

    So -ok i work in London city centre and i live 20 miles outside in essex. Can i afford a half a million pound property closer to work? I suppose i could find a job on my door step ,one i could role out of bed into that sounds a great idea in theory. I suppose i could sell up and yes as you say move one i can afford in todays current economic climate. You are right, but only i’m afraid in theory because practically it’s a no brainer isn’t it? Don’t you think everyone would like a job on their door step, and do you think they travel for the fun of it? Come on Martin the only people who would consider moving closer to work are people who get jobs abroad or jobs that are hundreds of miles away.

    Report abuse

  13. 13
    IAN PAYNE

    ………..and stupid unions !!!!!

    Report abuse

  14. 14
    Martin Davies

    For a distance of 30 miles each way for my wife, we would move house. For me, I simply work from home or work within reasonable bus travel distance. Though my jobs are all over the country, hers is a little more specialised so a lot less employer options.

    Report abuse



Free e-Supplements

Business Awards

Book a Business Awards table Book a Business Awards table

Join our celebrations of the region's best in business on Thursday March 22 - book your table now

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

entertainment

All the film reviews All the film reviews

Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases

OUR NEW APP

Get the new E&S app Get the new E&S app

Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.