Time to map out a plan for Villa's future
- Says blogger Matthew Turvey
Walsall blog: MK.Monstrosity
Friday 21st November 2008, 9:05AM GMT.
Walsall blogger Mark Jones’ posture will again experience comfort against a club he really has no time for – Milton Keynes Dons.
Who says us Walsall fans can’t get anything done by taking direct action?
Following on from my last blog, where I detailed three questions sent to the letters page in the programme, I can confirm that the club have moved with great urgency, so my seat will be fixed by Saturday. One down, two to go!
Many thanks to Dan Mole and Dave Storr at the club for their swift response.
Talking of Saturday, in my opinion a home fixture against the MK monstrosity is one which should not be taking place at all.
I know that the arguments against the franchise have been aired many times over the last five years but the fact that they are now a thriving, upwardly mobile League One club makes things worse in my eyes.
The unscrupulous owners of the old Wimbledon FC exploited a Football League loophole to enable the move to Milton Keynes, which effectively put an end to the real Dons.
That this particular loophole has now been closed tells me that those officials involved in sanctioning the appalling decision to allow the move in the first place know they were wrong to do so, but in true football administrator fashion they are too cowardly to reverse it.
Since then loads of money has been pumped into the MK project in order to make it work.
They have enough funds to outdo nearly all the competition at our level, a shiny new stadium (complete with its stupid ‘look how 21st.Century we are’ name) and lots of shiny new-born fans (I always wonder what they were doing 5 years ago).
The last time Walsall played there, in March 2007 at the old Hockey Stadium, at least half the home crowd seemed to have been plied with free tickets.
Whilst genuine football fans rightly continue to give MK the cold shoulder, certain sections of the media seem to think that their recent successes have given them some kind of legitimacy. Wrong, wrong, wrong, it hasn’t and it never will.
Clubs accelerating through the divisions thanks to the advantage gleaned from wealthy owner(s) is nothing new.
In many ways you can compare MK with Reading, clubs with large relatively affluent catchment areas, moving up into unchartered territory thanks to someone else’s generosity and a large slice of good fortune.
The difference is that Reading, like the rest of us, have a past full of ups and downs, highs and lows, with a history and tradition all of their own. Not one acquired in dubious circumstances.
Last year the MK management gained a lot of publicity for the cheap stunt of returning all of Wimbledon’s trophies, including the Crazy Gang’s 1988 FA Cup and the Amateur Cups from the Dons’ non-league days, to Merton Council.
Again this struck me as a recognition that it wasn’t theirs to give back anyway. More treacherously, it struck me as a tacit admission on MK’s part that they’d taken their unfair advantage to get what they wanted, used it up and tossed it out as soon as they’d got their thieving feet in the door.
So my solution is simple, if the people of MK are prepared to turn out to watch ‘their’ football club in Stadium Dot Dot MK, with Pete Winkleman and his cronies bankrolling it, fine.
But in recognition of the unsporting way they have got where they are today, they should be pay their dues and suffer demotion by three divisions to the Conference South (assuming the Conference boys actually want them).
Harsh, yes, but unprecedented, no. It has happened to other clubs. Boston have dropped three leagues in two years for financial shenanigans. Unfair maybe, but nowhere near as unfair as having your club given away.
If the MK club is as well-established as they’d like us to think then they’ll survive, prosper and maybe even earn themselves a bit of much-needed respect.
Will it ever happen? Well, as it would require a mix of imagination and backbone from those running the game, then never in a zillion years. We can dream though.
The only upside to the whole MK controversy has been the emergence of AFC Wimbledon, a club with spirit and integrity, established for and run by its own fans.
They’ve climbed through the lower reaches of non-league, ironically up to Conference South, over the past six years and created the blueprint for fans of other troubled clubs.
Proof, if it were ever needed, that whatever football club owners do, the heart and soul of a club is always with its fans.
Business Awards
Read the full story here
Full coverage of awards celebrating the region's best businesses.
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
LIVE traffic updates
Road, rail and airport - latest
Our new, live traffic and travel updates service - check before you set out.
OUR NEW APP
Get the new E&S app
Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.
Agree with every word of this. I hope the Saddlers hammer them.
Report abuse
Every word true.
Report abuse
Brilliant stuff. Well said. There are many, many people who share your views. Never forgive, never forget – say no to football franchising.
Report abuse
Hard luck today. I am a Wolves fan but very interested in the Wimbledon situation, having been to Plough Lane on a number of occasions before MK Dons were ever thought of. This is a very interesting article and I am sure that I am not alone in agreeing with the general sentiment.
Report abuse
By all accounts the Saddlers boycotted this fixture, as Walsall did not turn up.
On substantive matters the article has inaccuracies. E.g. first the ‘loophole’ still exists, (the rules still permit relocation of a club).
Second it was not the officials of the Football League which sanctioned the move to MK, but an independent FA Commission of Inquiry.
But do not let the facts get in the way of a rant.
The MK fans are following their local club which happens to be a club which moved from South London to MK in accordance with League rules.
Why some people are intent on stirring up unpleasantness about this is beyond all right thinking people.
Report abuse