Why the Net has the advantage in the ‘Undies world’
- Shopping blogger Emma Iannarilli
Decline began with a national ‘burglary’
Thursday 20th November 2008, 9:34AM GMT.
The present monetary problem has been brewing for a number of years. It is not something that has magically appeared.
I left school for the world of work some 60 years ago, just after the end of the Second World War. Like my friends, I obtained an apprenticeship, in my case as a model-maker and patternmaker, working in the industry. At that time this country’s balance of payments with the rest of the world was very strong.
Our industrial base accounted for 85 per cent to 88 per cent of the income of our strong economy; the rest came from the banking and insurance sectors.
At that time our industrial base was run either by those who owned the company, or managers who had full knowledge of the operations of the businesses, obtained through years of experience.
All companies paid into a training levy scheme, and those who did the training were able to obtain money to part-pay for this training. As a result of the Government’s shortsighted view, this scheme was scrapped. Training, to all intents and purposes, ceased.
Companies were later to have appointed to the board people who knew the cost of everything but unfortunately the value of nothing (accountants). This was the start of our decline as an industrial nation.
These people were unable to understand how best to use the money at their disposal. We started to see a large increase in administration staff and people overpaid for the job they were doing, hence the rising costs virtually killed off our industrial base.
During the late 1970s and early 1980s companies started being bought up by organisations intent only on asset stripping.
Lord Denning, with whom I agree, said at the time this was tantamount to burglary. Machinery was sold off to countries abroad.
We were told there was no demand for the product, but we now buy the produce made with this machinery.
As a result of our membership of the EU the remark attributed to Napoleon that “we are a country of shopkeepers” has come true.
D Winterborn, Broadlands Drive, Dudley.
Business Awards
Book a Business Awards table
Join our celebrations of the region's best in business on Thursday March 22 - book your table now
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
entertainment
All the film reviews
Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases
OUR NEW APP
Get the new E&S app
Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.
Funny really, I recall something different from that time period.
Poor quality goods, unions trying to create socialist societies inside factories, strikes, unions beating management to follow an ideal rather than what was practical.
And the workers pricing the goods out of the market.
We still have some industry, we have more car plants than many countries, we have plenty of smaller industries. Just we weren’t good enough and cheap enough to compete internationally in industry.
Not suprisingly the unions also kept equipment from being upgraded or replaced if it meant a job was lost.
Maybe its just me, but I’m glad we aren’t such an industrial nation as we used to be.
Just look at the impact of the credit crunch on the big carmakers in the USA.
We’d be in a far worse position if we still had so much industry and few places to sell to.
Times change. What was done 60 years ago isn’t the same as what needs doing now.
These days its even common for people to leave school with qualifications, maybe even go for a degree!
Oh, and we also have a much larger portion of the workforce who are women.
Times change. Things get better, or they get worse. They are certainly different.
Martin
Report abuse
“These days its even common for people to leave school with qualifications, maybe even go for a degree!”
And you don’t think a Fully Indentured and Apprenticed Skilled Tradesman is not a Qualification?……………
Report abuse
Martin, which planet have you been living on. I certainly do not agree with your comments. We used to be a proud nation, now we are a nation of shop keepers. Shame there will be few people who will be able to afford to buy the goods due to redundancies etc. It’s people like you who work on the theory of “I’m alright jack” Times have certainly changed and I for one think they have changed for the worse. Yes it certainly is “just you” and hopefully there will be few people who would agree with such a tunnelled view.
Report abuse
Woolibuga – did people leave school with that qualification or have to join the workforce first?
And when that industry dies, what then?
Jayne, we used to be a nation that did many things. Some good, some not so good. However we have only ourselves to blame for the way things have become.
We still have many different types of work, and still some industry. Just not as big as it used to be and certainly not requiring the same workforce we used to to make things.
Report abuse
The UK’s position as a nation that built things was because the rest of the world was underdeveloped, and the UK had tried very hard to keep it that way.
When the rest of the world broke free of colonial masters and learnt to build and make the things better and more cheaply than in the UK, purchasers (that’s you) decided to buy the better and cheaper goods from overseas.
I wonder if Woolibuga, Jayne Maclean and D Winterborn insist on only buying UK made goods, and always go on holiday in the UK, and make sure all of their savings is invested in UK companies because they think that UK companies are so great? Where was your tv made? Where was your car made? Oh, they’re not made in the UK are they? Hypocrites.
Report abuse
Rebeccas right we all want cheap goods in the shops and there not going to be british made. Trouble with the uk ,it priced itself out a long time ago and we were once the best at what we did. I’m sure we could manufacture laptops,tv’s,dvd players ,but would we be able to produce then as cheaply. Times do change Martin and everything comes around in a full circle. Just as we loose business abroad now because of price so our little empire will change again. I don’t think we are a nation of shop keepers just yet but we are getting there slowly.
Report abuse
Martin Davis! ….. No a “Skilled tradesman’ did not leave school with that “Qualification” but he/she did leave with a sound knowledge in the fundamentals that were a precursor to obtaining the skills through an Apprenticeship Program …. the opportunities were there until a Grocers Daughter and her Mealy Mouth Puppetmasters sold most of it off at Firesale prices…………..
Rebecca, You talk of underdeveloped countries and of them breaking free from Colonial Masters! …… You must be referring to The African Continent! ……… Why am I not surprised! ……. and now free from Odious Oppression aren’t they doing well .. Zimbabwe, Somalia, Sierra Leone, Angola to name a few ……….. all are basking in the glow of Industrial Prosperity ………. Give me a break!!………………….
We had the workforce and the skills and more important the ability to first with innovative technology ……. this was squandered by Stupid Government policies on both sides of the political spectrum and the intransigency of Trade Unions ……………..
Report abuse
I think we’ll agree on what government policy and trade unions did.
But we also were to blame, wanting quality goods cheap.
We even purchased cars that would do more than a few hundred miles without breaking down!
Say what you like about the stuff from abroad, they were beating us on quality.
Whereas we spent years thinking people would buy British because its BRITISH.
Go figure.
Report abuse
Rebecca, Do get off your soapbox! What a narrow minded and shallow person you are. If you are quite happy with what this Country has become, then more fool you. We are a nation of shopkeepers, the only problem here is that most of us won’t be able to visit the shops.
Report abuse
I hope we can all visit the shops and benefit from our 2% vat reduction. Wow i can feel a spending spree coming on.
Report abuse
Chris, its a 2.5% reduction. Down to the lowest we can get under EU rules.
Doesn’t mean the shops have to change their prices they charge us overall.
Just means the VAT amount added on is a little less.
Thye can set whatever price they want and pocket any extra.
Jayne, not sure about how we are a nation of shopkeepers. I’m a charity worker, never worked in a shop.
I’d say we are a nation with a wide range of jobs. Industrial, retail, commercial, financial, charity, service and government jobs.
Now if you want an industrial area, try in and around Detroit in the USA. Their car plants go under, the area is devastated. Rather reliant on car making – and who is buying?
Report abuse
Jayne – I’m a human being. The differences between British, French, Nigerian or Guatamalan human beings is minimal. Even the British can’t agree on what British is – the concept of “nationality” is entirely spurious. Are you 100% certain you’re 100% English? If so – what does that mean? Surely your ancestors were at some point Norman, Anglo-Saxon, Roman or even Celts, derived from settlers from India.
Why would anyone obsess so much over such arbitrary divisions? Secular Britain complains all the time about religion dividing people, so why is secular Britain so anxious to retain meaningless “national” divisions?
We’re all eager to benefit from globalisation when it comes to spending money – we want the cheapest there is. If we cared less about low price then people would be buying organic, local, recycled, fair trade – but they aren’t, so that means the general punter in the street doesn’t give a toss, they just want the cheapest product available.
But now you’re claiming that people should be buying British – overpriced, poor quality, poorly serviced, poorly maintained, unimaginatively designed?
Can’t you get your story straight, Jayne? You’re just talking about your prejudices, not about reason or objectivity or any debate based on intelligence.
Report abuse
True they can set the price and not give us any benefits of the vat reduction,but then again its not in their best interest is it? The retail trade needs us to spend and although we do have to spend our money, we can still choose where we spend our it. So rip off britain must think carefully if it wants to save its economy and it’s jobs,especially as our reatil trade is one of the largest single employers we have left
Report abuse
Considering the 20%+ sales some retailers have already had in the past few weeks, will we be spending more because of a hopeful 2.5% extra off?
To save the economy? Or save the house?
Thats the question. Spend, spend, spend now – just to save a bunch of shops. Or not spend, and put any spare money by to keep paying the bills.
Which, on an individual level, should people decide to do?
Report abuse