Birch’s Blog: It’s Miller time

Wednesday 12th November 2008, 8:00AM GMT.

ishamel-miller-camp.jpegSports Journalist Craig Birch discusses the merits of Albion striker Ishamel Miller in his first online blog.

As much as Albion fans would not like to entertain the prospect of relegation in their first season back in the top-flight, if that did become a reality most of the Baggies would point to one problem.

One of the biggest questions among folk down at the Hawthorns all season has been whether the team ultimately have the firepower to stay in the Premier League.

They remain one of the lowest scorers in the table so far, although they are from a defensive side, with Tony Mowbray’s men widely regarded as one of those that will try to play football.

When that happens, who inevitably gets the blame? The strikers. Or, in this case, Roman Bednar, Luke Moore and the subject of this blog, Ishamel Miller.

‘Big Ish’ has picked a difficult time to be the spearhead of the Albion strike force, especially with some fans still smarting from the departure of one of the deadliest finishers around in Kevin Phillips.

Effectively as new to the Premier League as Albion sre, Miller has drifted in and out of the team as club and player adapt to the top flight.

In the midst of this, he was maligned by teammate Roman Bednar – who needs to learn when to keep his mouth shut – after ‘going it alone’ against Middlesbrough.

He finally had an answer to his critics when on as a sub at Newcastle, scoring his first Premier League goal in the process. A thunderbolt against Blackburn followed.

All of a sudden, it is Miller rather than Bednar who looks like he may be the answer to Albion’s problems, although a thankless evening at Anfield has swelled momentum somewhat.

Now there is no doubt that a striker is needed to be brought to the Hawthorns in the transfer window. Three strikers is not enough anyway you divvy it up, so that is not up for debate.

But if a striker comes in – or even two as manager Tony Mowbray has suggested – should Miller be relegated to the role of back up? Certainly not.

In my eyes, Miller could become a real asset for Albion, if he is allowed time to grow and develop. People seem to forget that he is just 21 and will blow hot and cold, but if not persevered with over time will never be the finished article.

Granted, there are areas of his game that will never be any better. Granted, he does not use his strengths to full effect some of the time.

If he can sort the latter, how good would he be? Players with power and pace will always cause problems for defenders. Can Bednar or Moore really have the same effect?

Miller reminds me a lot of Emile Heskey as a young player at Leicester. A man mountain of raw energy, flawed at times but with the natural ability to haul a promoted side up the table with sheer impact.

Heskey currently resides as a coveted England centre-forward, such as his game evolved, so what can Miller achieve?

The impact that Miller had when he first came to the club can happen again, when the player finds his feet fully.

If that happens, Albion could have more of an asset on their hands than many would think.


  1. 1
    The Real Nedball

    Miller can be excellent when he’s blowing ‘hot’, but his ‘cold’ days are Arctic!!

    If he’s guided in a positive manner, as I believe TM is doing with him currently, he will be an asset for years to come.

    Quite possibly the most infuriating player I’ve seen at the Albion, as he can murder 3 players without trying, but then will run into more players, or pick the wrong option at the vital moment.

    Time is on his side though, and I hope he can continue to grow as a player in the Premier League with WBA and Tony Mowbray as his mentor.

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    maltawolf

    2 goals in 2 games suddenly on fire,2 goals in 10 games not good enough,all strikers have bad patches but why did Man City let him go so easily.
    Would love to see him develop and fire the goals to keep you lot up but can you really see it?

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    Clapham Wolf

    Good in the championship not good enough for the premiership

    Still a young lad though so you never know.

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    Exmouth Albion

    I have to agree with Clapham. Might be ok for the odd game or to come off the bench for the last twenty minutes but he should not be our main striker in the prem.

    Good for the Championship not good enough for the Premiership could be said for many players…including Kevin Phillips at his age now.

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    the black pearl

    2) there are many cases of managers letting players go because they don’t “fancy them”. the premier league teams generally buy finished articles, or starlets that they can slot into a huge squad with it’s world class players. ramsey at arsenal, as well as walcott in the last couple of years spring to mind. with the time miller has spent on the pitch it’d prob be about 2 goals in 6 games. he’s young and raw and possesses the attributes to become a very good player. it is obvious though we need a box predator though, so our very good approach play can be rewarded. it isn’t about miller keeping us up, it’s about the whole squad performing. we also need goals from midfield, which are also lacking at the minute. i’m still convinced that TM will keep us up and our team when fully fit is far superior to the one that won the championship.

    Report abuse

  6. 6
    pip

    Miller yes i fancy him to do well,needs support,an experienced prem striker next to him,think Baggies need to tighten up against the top sides,but keep playing attacking football against the rest.Its tight in the Prem this season.Baggies to stay up and wolves to get promoted,that would be brill,loacal derby in the prem.

    Report abuse

  7. 7
    Hall Green Baggie

    I cast my vote on the “stick with him, will be very good” side.

    Report abuse

  8. 8
    Happy_baggie

    I remember listening to Mark Hughes being interviewed after taking over at man city – and he was gutted that Sven had allowed Ish to leave – he really wanted him at the club.

    He may not be the finished article, and he may be finding the prem a hard place – but the lad has real talent – he WILL be a great player… just stick with him and give him our support.

    Report abuse



Free e-Supplements

Business Awards

Read the full story here Read the full story here

Full coverage of awards celebrating the region's best businesses.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

LIVE traffic updates

Road, rail and airport - latest Road, rail and airport - latest

Our new, live traffic and travel updates service - check before you set out.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new E&S app Get the new E&S app

Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.