Nice idea, but who would do service?

Wednesday 27th August 2008, 9:20AM BST.

I see that yet again in the Letters page there is a fond plea for the return of National Service.

I make no comment as to the merits or otherwise of this idea, but what does interest me is the question of exactly who would perform this duty?

There appears to be a tacit assumption that the performance of National Service would be carried out by young men only (as in yesteryears) but how can this be correct in this day and age? Many very senior positions are held by women in our armed forces as well as our emergency services, so to exclude women from National Service simply on the grounds that they are female would be an act of blatant sexism, would it not? Well, wouldn’t it?

Would single mothers be called upon to serve? And if not, will unmarried fathers be excused National Service also? If not, why not?

Also, could or should National Service be avoided if a person sought to claim that being in the military would lead them into conflict with persons who share their faith or ethnic origins?

The entire topic of a possible return to the days of National Service raises many more questions than can be reasonably answered. However, in the unlikely event of its re-implementation I foresee an explosion of teenage pregnancies, an entire army of men actually wanting to claim paternity; and entire battalions of lawyers engaged in (financially lucrative) legal battles to have their clients excused National Service for whatever reason that is currently politically correct or convenient.

S Lamberton, Station Road, Aldridge.


  1. 1
    Rebecca

    Wow, someone who reads the Express & Star and also considers the implications of the fascist ideas that the readers suggest. If the Express & Star readers ruled the country, would the rest of the world declare war on us like the Allies declared war on Fascist Germany in 1939 – 45?

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    Martin Davies

    I’ve met quite a few people who did national service. Many of them saw it as makework – something to keep them busy rather than something useful.
    Never quite figured out what we’d do with a bunch of conscripts except during wartime.

    Good to see others questioning what was never a brilliant idea the first time we did it.

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    Joe

    The entire topic of National Service raises many more questions than can be reasonably answered”

    Not really: all questions can be reasonably answered… by educated and reasonoble people.

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    chris

    Forcing people to join the armed forces at gun point is ot my idea of fun. I havn’t spent a large portion of my life bringing up my kids only to have their lives wiped out in a short moment of time in an out back place like afghanistan. I do repsect dearly those people who choose to join up and fight for their queen and country, and i only hope that if they are seriously hurt that they are looked after and treated the way they should be.

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    woolibuga

    As an Ex National Serviceman I read the above comments with some amusement …… If you don’t want an Army of conscripts then you must settle for an Army of Yobs and Louts and we see a daily ever increasing liturgy of the effect this is having on todays society.

    I was “Called Up” like so many others of my age group and whilst I agree that service life was not for everyone to the vast majority it was a time of benefit ….. it bought the “Bumptious Down” and the “Not so Confident Up” ….. I for one remember the life skills Discipline and Regimentation that my time as a National Serviceman taught me ….. in fact I enjoyed it so much I signed on and served in places in the World that I probably would never seen …….. so I say Bring it On!…………………

    Report abuse



Free e-Supplements

Business Awards

Book a Business Awards table Book a Business Awards table

Join our celebrations of the region's best in business on Thursday March 22 - book your table now

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

entertainment

All the film reviews All the film reviews

Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases

OUR NEW APP

Get the new E&S app Get the new E&S app

Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.