Time to map out a plan for Villa's future
- Says blogger Matthew Turvey
Sad tales of NHS failure
Thursday 3rd July 2008, 10:45AM BST.
This week marks the 60th anniversary of the NHS, 60 years of great triumphs, staggering technological advancement and a pioneering concept of free health care for everyone brought to fruition, writes blogger Charlie Cashdan.
This bright and fantastic initiative to allow everyone access to free treatment was, of course, brilliant and necessary in it’s infancy but 60 years down the line and the NHS is seriously over burdened, under-funded and riddled with problems.
Start a conversation about the NHS anywhere, with any group of people and at least one person will have a horror story to tell. These range from rude consultants and lost notes to more serious situations involving MRSA and shocking neglect of the elderly.
Access to a local GP is a particular soapbox favourite of mine. All other service industries are set up to provide access to their services at key times when the majority of their customers will want access to them. They are customer driven and the costumer comes first regardless.
I worked in retail for many years and still supply the retail industry and my staff are expected to work late nights, Saturdays and Sundays. Failure to do this restricts their ability to get work. I have worked in catering and the pub trade, also accessible evenings and weekends when people need them. So why can’t doctors provide the same?
Why should people have to miss time at work incurring hassle and often loss of pay just because a doctor who probably earns four times as much as them, doesn’t fancy doing a Saturday shift? How very old fashioned and completely out of touch with the modern world for any service professional to work a 9-5 Monday to Friday only schedule!
You seem to get a wildly differing picture of the NHS depending on whom you speak to.
My father is retired and is therefore able to go to the doctors whenever he needs to. He never has a problem getting an appointment. He had a heart attack some years ago and received excellent care from his local surgery and hospital.
My husband has always received faultless service whenever he has been hospitalised, so have my stepsons.
My mother and myself have had nothing but a complete catalogue of errors because it seems very much to me that unless you go to the doctors/hospital with something obvious and are a man, no one takes you very seriously.
I went back and forth from doctors and various hospitals between the ages of 5 to 24 with a painful urinary complaint which I had suffered with from birth. The mistreatment, misdiagnoses, horribly rude consultants and errors experienced during those years would fill several blogs!
I decided that I had experienced enough and it was better to just suffer alone than continue with the NHS so I didn’t see a doctor about my problems again for 6 years. The pain has become increasingly difficult to manage of late and my husband persuaded me to try again this year and after a six-year wait I was full of hope that things may have improved.
I was so wrong.
After waiting six years, the consultant spent four minutes with me at my first appointment and was so abrupt I left the room and sobbed.
I returned for my second appointment and waited over an hour while the consultant saw everyone else in the waiting room. When I was the only person remaining, he left the consulting room, walked through the waiting room and disappeared.
My husband and I presumed that he had just gone for a quick break but the registrar called us through and explained he had been called to an emergency. The registrar was quite kind and tried to help but we then discovered that he had the wrong notes. A search began to find the correct ones detailing all my treatment over the years but they could not be found.
I then had to try and remember all my complex medical history and we concluded that the next step would be an MRI scan.
When my appointment came weeks later it was not for an MRI as expected but for an ultrasound scan, of which I’ve had at least ten already!
Dutifully, I went along to the appointment and got scanned with an ancient scanner that couldn’t really show any detail and subsequently found nothing.
That was over three months ago and I haven’t heard from the hospital at all since. Clearly they have lost interest leaving me completely stuck, as I can’t afford private treatment.
I have spoken to countless women over the years all telling similar stories of having to fight and push for a diagnosis.
I don’t deny that the NHS has saved many lives and can provide fantastic treatment. The nurses in particular have always been excellent to me and they work so hard for so little pay that I have much respect for them. I just wish that my overall experience of the service had been better and that we were all viewed as customers rather than patients because changing that one little word could mean a big change in attitudes.
Agree with Charlie? What is your experience of the NHS? Post your comments below.
Business Awards
Read the full story here
Full coverage of awards celebrating the region's best businesses.
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
LIVE traffic updates
Road, rail and airport - latest
Our new, live traffic and travel updates service - check before you set out.
OUR NEW APP
Get the new E&S app
Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.
Has Charlie Cashdan ever experienced health care in a different country – one in which healthcare is not equally available to all? I feel that if she had, she would be much less scathing of our struggling health service.
As a newly qualified doctor I have just returned from a placement abroad where there is no welfare available, where everyone old and young has to pay for investigation and treatment and where patients frequently go without quality of life-enhancing procedures because they simply cannot afford it.
I am sorry that Mrs Cashden feels that she has not recieved what she feels is the perfect standard of care. I am well aware of the limitations and frustrations of the modern NHS. Prior to my medical training I worked at the frontline of the NHS as a radiographer however I feel strongly that the ethics of treatment and patient care are outstanding within a very complex and at times impossible work-load. It is very short-sighted of people such as Mrs Cashdan to dismiss the NHS as sad and a failure. Whilst there are failures within the NHS, it cannot be likened to a private retail, catering or pub industry. It simply is not a money-making industry. Advances in medicine mean that healthcare has become very expensive, financial demand far outweighing supply. The HNS is the countries biggest employer, many of it’s staff, GP’s included (is the blogger aware of how much training is required to become a GP and what a medical trainee has to give up in order to be successful?) work selflessly to maintain quality of care for the patients. With staff morale already at an all time low I call Mrs Cashden to be more empathic and see the bigger picture of the modern NHS.
Report abuse
“How very old fashioned and completely out of touch with the modern world for any service professional to work a 9-5 Monday to Friday only schedule!”
Err-how about judges, lawyers, solititors, dentists, builders, painters and decorators, local council offices, MPs?
Most GPs actually open 8-6.30 and some open Saturday. I assume the staff you know who work evenings and weekends do it for money rather than goodwill. Why do you therefore expect GPs to work around the clock for goodwill. If you want to see your GP at midnight it can be done but it would mean your taxes would go up to pay for it.
Report abuse
“….. for an ultrasound scan, of which I’ve had at least ten already”
I take it you were not paying for these then?
No wonder the hospitals are struggling where you are!
Report abuse
“….. for an ultrasound scan, of which I’ve had at least ten already”
I take it you were not paying for these then?
No wonder the hospitals are struggling where you are!
Report abuse
Rachel, i do try to see the bigger picture of the NHS but it’s really hard to think of that at times like this morning when i was in so much pain i could hardly stand, i was incontinent, and trying to just get ready for work was a nightmare! I just get so frustrated that no one can help despite going to three different hospitals and seeing many consultants. I know i’m lucky to have been seen for free but rarely ever go to a doctor about anything else (about ten times in my whole life!) so i try not to be a burden. A lot of my treatment has made my pain worse too and i’m now absolutely terrified of hospitals. I’ll never forget the kindness of the nurses and one particular consultant who did try really hard to help, i just wish someone could make me better!
In response to Xavier, i don’t expect GPs to work extra hours, but if there is more than one GP in a practice I don’t see why they can’t rota shifts to cover more hours collectively. For example, Dr X does 9 till 6, Dr Y does 10.30-7 and Dr Z does 12 till 8. Dr X does Saturday and Sunday one week and gets two days off in the week, then someone else does the following weekend. I know it’s not quite that simple, but you get the picture! I don’t need to see a Dr at midnight, but none of our local GP surgeries do any weekend shifts.
My staff don’t get any extra pay for lates and weekends, it’s just classed as normal hours for retail and if they cover a late, they just start later in the day so get paid exactly the same.
Yes my ten ultrasounds were free, but ten spread out over twenty years isn’t too much of a burden really especially considering i took a six year break despite being in pain every day. I have friends who are up at the Drs most weeks and i can go for years without seeing a Dr except for this problem. I think all the binge drinkers (i don’t drink at all), smokers (i don’t smoke), drug takers (God no!) and seriously overweight people (rounder than I should be admittedly) are probably the more likely cause of struggling local hospitals than me with ten ultrasounds in twenty years! I haven’t even had a child on the NHS and avoid Drs like the plague for everyday things – i even just got stuff from the chemist to treat two very bad bouts of food poisoning and spent over £40 at the chemist treating another problem because i couldn’t get time off work to see my GP. I really don’t mean to be a burden and wish desperately that one ultrasound had been enough to find what causes my pain so that doctors could make me well.
Report abuse