Thug who attacked horse jailed

Thursday 13th March 2008, 3:00PM GMT.

Matthew CorfieldA thug who repeatedly hurled a butcher’s meat cleaver at a horse which later had to be put down was today sent to a young offenders’ institution for five months.

Matthew Corfield, pictured, aged 19, of Higgs Road, Wednesfield, laughed as he inspected the 12-inch by five-inch blade for blood, the court was told earlier.

Co-accused Alex Lister, aged 19, of Olinthus Avenue, Wednesfield, who chased the horse and tried to film two men including Corfield, running after it, with his mobile phone, was told to carry out 180 hours of community work.

He pleaded guilty to causing unnecessary suffering to a protected animal on the basis he was not aware of the meat cleaver.

Maggie, a 19-year-old mare, suffered horrific injuries following the attack at Essington Hall Farm, Essington on April 13 last year.

Corfield, who also admitted causing unnecessary suffering to an animal, had been drinking with friends including Lister earlier.

Maggie’s heartbroken owner Davina Bowyer, aged 47, from Essington, told the Express & Star a major part of her life had been taken away and that she loved the horse, which she had raised for 18 years.

At Cannock Magistrates Court Lister were also ordered to pay costs.

Chairman of the bench Mirendra Raval told Corfield: “This was a nasty incident – a prolonged attack on an innocent horse.”


  1. 1
    DEAN

    FIVE MONTHS WHAT A ******* JOKE

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    ET

    Sounds like a clear repeat of the “Great Wyrley Atrocities” of the early 20th century where a Wyrley solicitor was erroneously sentenced to 7 years in prison for attacking horses. The book “Arthur and George” is based around Conan Doyle’s actions to free George Edalj who was innocent.

    Funny that the sentence was 7 years then and 5 months now !

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    Karen

    The birch too should be given to evil people like this. Five months is nothing compared to what he has done
    to the family of Maggie, and especially how Maggie was killed.

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    Posh Side of Wolvo

    These sick, perverted people should be locked up and the key thrown away. Mind you, I saw people dressed up, chasing a fox with a pack of rabid dogs the other day. The objective being to tear the fox to pieces. Hmmmm, any difference?

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    MSP

    Another example of todays youth attitude – anything for a laugh – in their own small minded way. Nothing surprises anyone in todays society, but what’s the answer ?

    Report abuse

  6. 6
    JCH

    Scum bag.. it’s about time people were punished in this country

    Report abuse

  7. 7
    Giggsy

    7, I am right with you there ma mon.

    He is a disgusting human being.

    4, Well said.

    Report abuse

  8. 8
    Ken Hawthorn

    From the look of his photo’ the prat looks
    exactly what he is, an imbecile, years ago he
    would have been comitted to an asylum.
    I agree with every comment & Mark what goes
    around comes around.

    Report abuse

  9. 9
    Tanky

    It was so sweet watching Corfield being led away in cuffs! So, so sweet but not nearly enough! ROT IN HELL MATT!

    Report abuse

  10. 10
    ANDREW44

    THE PARENTS MUST BE PROUD. KNOWING THAT THEY’VE BROUGHT UP SUCH A WONDERFUL HUMAN BEING.

    HE WILL GET HIS REWARDS, I’M PRETTY SURE PEOPLE WILL REMEMBER THE FACE. LOOKS LIKE HE’LL HAVE TO WATCH HIS BACK WHEN HE GETS OUT.

    Report abuse

  11. 11
    A writer

    8 – He is not a human being, he is a pathetic excuse of one.

    5 months is a total joke, and as for the court costs!!! well what about some sort of compensation payable to the owner?

    Corfield is only one of them that was caught, what about the others that were there with him and Lister??

    I hope they rot in hell

    Report abuse

  12. 12
    carol

    As this was such a “nasty incident”, as quoted, why didn’t the “nasty man” get a “nasty sentance” to go with it, hardly punishing him for his crime, he will be out after about a month for “good behaviour”, he probably knows how to work the system, has he apologised, or shown remorse, I doubt it!

    Report abuse

  13. 13
    expatwolf

    if i wrote my true feelings about this i would probably get sent to jail for it…and probably for longer than a mere 5 months

    Report abuse

  14. 14
    CH

    I think that piece of scum should watch his back coz maybe someone might come after him with a meat
    cleaver!!

    Report abuse

  15. 15
    devonwolf

    I sincerily hope the 5 months will be the hardest of his life and he gets taught a lesson he will never forget forget.

    Report abuse

  16. 16
    wolfmeister

    Absolute joke.5 months of which he’ll serve half if hes a good boy. Young offenders institute so lots of group hugs and plaaystation time.
    My other half was talking to a prison officer client the other day who has had enough, prisoners have more rights than the officers and they know it. Prisoners are release early on the quite etc its a joke.
    I wonder if the sentence would have been the same if the horses owner was an MP for example.

    Report abuse

  17. 17
    Shelley

    Another perfect example of the appalling British justice system. Definately, what goes around comes around..

    Report abuse

  18. 18
    deb

    That is a terrible joke… 5 months is nothing and the scary thing is he probably thinks he is really clever and hard!

    Report abuse

  19. 19
    Kat

    I can’t believe he only got 5 months, what is this country coming to when attacking a horse in this way only gets 5 months. He obviously does not care as he was laughing throughout the proceedings. In my opinion he has no remorse and no care for what he did so lock him up and never let him out.

    Report abuse

  20. 20
    steve

    these people are scum – the parents must be so proud – scumbags

    Report abuse

  21. 21
    DCI Gene Hunt

    Should have let him spend 6 months “rehab” with me! Who’s gonna have his brain cell whilst he’s inside? No doubt I’ll be nicking him for benefit fraud once he’s out………

    Report abuse

  22. 22
    cashy

    he should be made to pay for a new horse for the owner,then he should be sent to serve his country in iraq for a few years

    Report abuse

  23. 23
    moikel

    dont send him to a detention centre, like all mad animals, he should be DESTROYED…i apologise to all animals for calling this thing an animal….i hope there are animal lovers in the detention centre.!!!!!!

    Report abuse

  24. 24
    kai

    I think they put down the wrong animal!! This boy is a clear example of a raising amount of immoral youths in society

    Report abuse

  25. 25
    kai

    I think they put down the wrong animal!

    Report abuse

  26. 26
    Bob

    Since when has someone over 18 ( classed legally as an adult ) warranted a “young offenders” order. He should be dealt with as an adult even though he is a moron. Mind he was no better at 14 ( personal experience) and will be no better on release. The apple never falls far from the tree !

    Report abuse

  27. 27
    L. Luke

    So by the Summer, both will resume their lives ??
    Davina’s life is shattered and someone, somewhere has to realise that the public will not tolerate this mindless, violence. We are sick to death of seeing these sickening acts over and over again and still there is no deterent ?!
    He is 19 and yet has the protection of a youth offenders prison… holidays / days out / sport …. i cannot take this in. Let him out for a day with animal lovers and we can decide what he deserves.

    Report abuse

  28. 28
    paul

    if i seen him i wold do it to him. come on five months i am so up set about it

    Report abuse

  29. 29
    comma

    this lad and he took the rap for being the only one to hold up his hands and admit to being there, the others however did not.

    At least he had the balls to accept his punishment…

    how can an asylum seeker get away with hit and run when this kind of crime warrants 6 months?

    rich folk with money can make anything happen

    Report abuse

  30. 30
    Rob

    Scum…..no other words I can think of

    Report abuse

  31. 31
    Val

    Five months for mutilation – what would it be if his victim was human? Of course, the horse can’t claim from Criminal Injuries – so that’s all right.

    That snot-ape should be watched from the minute he’s released. Prison for his type will be an education rather than a punishment.

    Report abuse

  32. 32
    Penelope Pitstop

    Well lets hope this is the last crime they commit but I VERY MUCH DOUBT IT! From the gutter will stay in the gutter and yes KARMA

    Report abuse

  33. 33
    Bentley gal

    Justice 4 Maggie!!!
    These prats should of got longer, but at least it is better than nothing…
    At least these scum bags didnt get away with it!!!
    R.I.P Maggie!!!

    Report abuse

  34. 34
    Richard

    Five months =20 weeks out of that he will probably do 10 weeks and be free. They should put him in a field with wild horses and lets see the damage they do to him (SCUM)

    Report abuse

  35. 35
    .

    However, not one of you know him.
    And not one of you would want to or be able to go through what he has to be where he is now, full of regret and heartbroken.
    You call him a waste of space, when you spend your lives criticising something that you know nothing about.
    I think it’s atrocious what you’re doing, he’s in prison now, your nasty words don’t hurt him, they hurt his innocent family.

    Report abuse

  36. 36
    l thomas

    The sentence received is a joke, a further fine of £20,000
    might of been a nice little sting for the wicked b@stards
    The punishment does not fit the crime in this case
    I would of locked them both up for a very very long time.
    ( After putting them in a public stock for a week or so first )

    Report abuse

  37. 37
    Ozpat

    Five bloody months, that sentence in itself is an insult to the victims of this crime. As for the scumbag seen here he and his cohorts need a fuller length sentence with hard bloody labour and then publicly named and shamed on release.

    Report abuse

  38. 38
    sam

    Pathetic sentance.
    degenerates like that are not fit to hold a place in our society.

    Report abuse

  39. 39
    IAN PAYNE

    THUG 1 – HORSE AND JUSTICE 0 !!!!

    Report abuse

  40. 40
    SPRI

    Best thing to do with them is experiment on then in a vivisection Lab, save some poor animal from the cruelty of pain, that happens in those sort of places.
    I’d be willing to plug then into a electric char and push the button.

    Report abuse

  41. 41
    SPRI

    Posh Side of Wolves.

    I agree, Fox Hunters, are no differant, except for 1 thing, they have a lot of money well most do, and they call if fun. Isn’t it against the Law now.?
    Lets do som recersing of rols, and put those “people” in a ring and get chased by lions. Hmm romans had something.!!!

    Report abuse

  42. 42
    Dave Philips

    5 months is a disgrace. This moron needs to be locked up for 10 years!

    Too many do gooders in this country, it’s time for people to start paying ‘properly’ for their crimes.

    A defenceless horse is now dead and in 5 months time this piece of sh** will be free again. I mean honestly the people that do this do not deserve to live in my mind.

    Report abuse

  43. 43
    C.K. Truth.

    We see these “beasts” being given psychological evaluation, reabilitated and allowed to roam the streets in a society which as supposed to have grown, supposed to show more compassion and yet… five months for cruelly attacking an animal, a defenseless victim. Victims (animal or human) continue to be victimized and the monsters allowed to walk among us. A dog bites someone they get put down. A monster butchers and tortures an animal but thats okay. Humans are supposed to know better, animals don’t. If they are “sick” then put the ******* down like the animals who bite. I am sick of do gooders getting perverts off who rape and murder children, who go around attacking animals, old people and others who cannot defend themselves. The sickest part of it is. AGAIN the victims and taxpayers have to pay for these monsters to live.
    Let us start taking back what is ours and stop letting these sicko’s get away with such crimes.
    Enough already of this nonsense “but we can help them.” I can too! Lethal injection, gladly paid for, see ya!
    No wonder we see more and more crime, and less and less respect.

    Report abuse

  44. 44
    C.K. Truth.

    One final note: Fox hunting. Only reason it exists is because of the rich and powerful participate. No other reason. If farmers need to protect their land and livestock then there are more humane ways of doing it than a pack of vicious dogs ripping the poor creature apart after being terrorised by a pack of vicious half-breeds with snotty noses… just rich bloodthirsty rodents at best.

    Report abuse

  45. 45
    true friends

    Matt we know you better than the people here.

    wev seen you get in a fight because you tried to stop some lads kicking a pigeon in town…

    we know that what was reported was not the real truth. they made an example of you because you meddled with wealthy folk.

    god forbit they ever get thrown to the lions like you did… we know the true you

    Report abuse

  46. 46
    facts4u

    heres a few facts the mob werent told:

    -no weapon was ever recovered or proven to exist.
    -pc munnerly intimidated people into making statements to push a court case
    -There was no smiling in court, only remorse

    You think you are given enough information to pass judgement on these youths. NOT at all…

    Lets hope none of you evcer get labelled a paedophile or rapist… youl be subject to the same public slaughter

    Report abuse

  47. 47
    Justice 4 Maggie!!!

    In response to comment number 35 you do not know what you are talking about!!! I was in court and there was no remorse from Corfield!! He committed the crime and so must pay the consequences (be that prison or hate mail). Corfield only held his hands up as there was too much evidence against him!! How about leaving a horse there to die and not calling anyone!! He had many opportunities to plead guilty along the way and didn’t. It was even heard in court that he called one of witnesses and asked them to say it was not him!!! As for his family, his dad didn’t seem to be suffering too much when he turned to Davina in court and said “I hope you are happy now”. So next time you decide to post a comment in their favours, make sure you have the full facts!!!

    Report abuse

  48. 48
    poor horse owner

    It is not wealth that put Matty!!! behind bars, it was pure determination and commitment from alot of upset people. Most horse owners have to work long hard hours to keep their horses and are most certainatly not rich!! And as for stopping someone kicking a pigeon “ARE YOU HAVING A LAUGH!”

    Report abuse

  49. 49
    More facts

    The police did recover the meat cleaver and have it in their possesion. Shame comment 46 was not in court!!!

    Report abuse

  50. 50
    CN

    True Friend!!! – Shut up! Your only as bad as the people you choose to hang around with!

    If the owner had confronted him and done anything to stop him – what would the owner have got?!

    He should be given a longer sentence in a MAN’s prison where someone might show him or do something to him which will be with him for the rest of his life!

    Look at his face………What a complete T*AT!!!!

    Report abuse

  51. 51
    Justice

    True friends……

    Meddled with rich folk? Are you completely stupid? There are people that own horses who are wealthy i.e. show jumpers and race horse owners and there are people like Davina Bowyer who just kept her horse as pets – what the hell has money got to do with what your friend has done?

    Your friend Matt, put Maggie through a whole night of terror and agonising pain. He cut her up and left her to suffer all night.

    She was lying in a sea of her own blood when she was found in agony.

    If you do know the REAL Matt, as you say, then you will protect yourself by staying away from him, he is a dangerous man!

    Facts4u……..

    You obviously weren’t in court – AGAIN. Matt’s own cousin made a statement saying that Matt contacted him and asked him to dispose of the knife. The court has ordered the knife to be destroyed now.

    AND – there was smiling in court today, we all had a good smile as Matt Corfield was led away in cuffs!

    You must be from the same blood lines facts4u, as you obviously do not know right from wrong either!

    Report abuse

  52. 52
    Bentley gal

    These people are scum and their sentence was not long enough as if he is a good boy then he will only get half his time.
    What happened to Maggie was don’t right wrong and there was no need 4 it what so ever!!!
    I think the news yesterday proved quite alot, and the video..
    i like the way they added that in…
    Not so shy now!!!
    R.I.P Maggie!!!

    Report abuse

  53. 53
    VickiH

    Personally, I hope the people that did this ARE suffering, I hope they are full of remorse and that what they have done messes up their lives. Just like they have messed up Davina. I don’t care whether they showed remorse in court or not, they shouldn’t have done it in the first place.

    Those of you defending them on here today should think twice – there is NO reason on earth to justify what they did.

    Report abuse

  54. 54
    Posh Side of Wolvo

    the comment about the family being upset & the pscho being upset & full of regret? didnt hitlers ss say similar things after the concentration camps (im surethe current looney would be at home working there). ref comments on the other pervs – fox hunters, yes it is illegal, but the money, power & influence of these vandals of the countyside means they are above the law & just carry on terrorising harmless wild animals, pets & maiming horses. Now if you or i went bagger baiting???? 6 months lad!

    Report abuse

  55. 55
    Grey PBA

    As a horse owner I cannot describe how revolted and angry this makes me feel. Horses are prey animals – they need to escape from danger… these VILE VILE thugs trapped this
    horse for what? their own fun? What a pity that a powerful horse’s instincts don’t
    drive it to turn around and attack…we would have all cheered if they had been kicked and trampled to death!

    SICK.. their values must spill over into their lives
    generally – I cannot imagine that this is ‘out of character’ to them.

    Poor Maggie and poor Davina – left with the aftermath of this.

    The thugs poor family ??? yeah right – you have raised a thug with a warped set of
    values. What goes around comes around – hopefully.

    Report abuse

  56. 56
    emma hanna kellie :)

    we all think that this is disgraceful
    he should be ashamed at himself
    and should get sooooo much more than 5 stinkin months
    people like this are just dirty skumbags
    any need….i think not

    Report abuse

  57. 57
    DD

    comment 45…did he try to stop a lad kicking the pigeon so he could kick it himself!!
    dont’ matter what people say they cannot ever EVER justify what they did, peer pressure, forced into it, whatever, we all have a choice in life believe it or not, sadly some people make very bad ones! hope you have a really hard time for what you did.

    Report abuse

  58. 58
    Mr. E

    senseless little goofy prat.
    these are subtle and mild words to describe the behavious of this total cretin.
    How would he like it? being battered senselessly with a knife and left to rot in agonising pain, in puddle of his own blood.

    we could all go on all day and all night about how much of a joke the system has become. this case and sentance certainly proves it.

    there are people who posted comments on here attempting to defend the thug.
    and why?
    look at him. no remorse, no sense of guilt or sorrow for what he has done.
    id second guess to wether he is even aware of what he has done, dosent appear to be with all his faculties to me.
    those defending him, put yourselves in the horse’s place. how would you like to be treated in such a way by a vile imbocile?
    this is how he gets his kicks it would appear?
    well we would all takle great pleasure im sure in getting out kicks, by avenging the horse and giving him a dam good kicking.
    but then of course, we’d all get locked up and for much longer.

    Report abuse

  59. 59
    Karen

    When does the punishment EVER fit the crime in this
    god forsaken country – Great Britain “my arse” as
    Jim Royle would say

    Report abuse

  60. 60
    Justice

    Remorse???? As Corfield was led away he was shaking his head as if he couldn’t believe it – THEN, his dad turned to Davina and said “are you satisfied now”.

    They didn’t look or sound very sorry!

    His mother shouted “we love you son” – HOW COULD YOU LOVE THAT? Sorry but if I did something only hald as bad as what he did – my parents would beat the life out of me, I wouldn’t have even made it to court.

    Report abuse

  61. 61
    richy rich

    you people make me sick. the law has given the highest punishment available.

    no doubt you will all be out this weekend slaughtering foxes and badgers right?

    maybe that will satisfy your thirst for blood!

    in my opinion your as bad as the teens involved.

    watch you dont end up inside with them

    Report abuse

  62. 62
    hannah

    the uppercrust of society always believe they are worse off than the rest of us but continue to practice their own fox hunting, shooting passtimes as its traditional… pot calling the kettle black

    get over it the guilty have been named and punished, thats now on their record for life

    Report abuse

  63. 63
    response2comment49

    so why wasnt it shown in court… it didnt exist

    hearsay, conjecture, gossip.. thats was the only evidence

    if the lad hadnt admitted it the court would have thrown it out.

    Report abuse



Free e-Supplements

Business Awards

Book a Business Awards table Book a Business Awards table

Join our celebrations of the region's best in business on Thursday March 22 - book your table now

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

entertainment

All the film reviews All the film reviews

Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases

OUR NEW APP

Get the new E&S app Get the new E&S app

Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.