Concert review: Roger Waters’ The Wall, Birmingham NIA

Tuesday 28th June 2011, 9:35AM BST.

Roger Waters' The Wall, at Birmingham NIA

Roger Waters’ The Wall
Birmingham NIA
Concert review by Keith Harrison

You’d better sit down for this: Seventy five quid a ticket, plus another £11 booking fee – and yet this breathtaking show was still underpriced.

Because this wasn’t so much a modern reworking of one of the biggest albums of all time, it was a 90-minute sensory assault.

Click on the image to the right for our concert photo gallery

In the first two songs alone, fireworks had greeted Waters, a  Messerschmitt had ‘flown’ the length of the arena before crashing onto the stage in flames and a 35-foot tall inflatable teacher waved a giant cane at a school choir, each bearing a lettered t-shirt spelling out the words ‘Fear builds walls’.

That was just the start of a spectacular evening of dark imagery and special effects which had audience members nudging each other to point out things happening on and off stage they were in danger of missing.

There was the giant pig floating round the auditorium, the ‘helicopter’, the surround sound wizardry, the fold-out hotel suite and the closing shower of poppies, which on closer inspection turned out to be in the shape of the Shell oil logo, as Waters ramped up the anti-war message for 2011.

And through it all, the Wall itself; 40 foot high and spanning the width of the NIA as black shirted acolytes gradually obscured Waters and his band from view in the first half with huge cardboard bricks.

The giant screen this created was used so effectively with harrowing video and stills that there were times when the 67-year-old himself looked like a long-legged Gerald Scarfe hologram playing a bit part in his own semi-autobiographiocal tale. S

o rich was the imagery that it almost broke the spell when Waters spoke to the audience as himself before diving back into  the troubled world played out on screen before the Wall was spectacularly torn down in the finale.

Stunning doesn’t begin to describe it.

Music photography by Ian Harvey / RocktasticPix


  1. 1
    garry

    I saw this magnificent show in manchester last month, one of the greatest shows ever!!
    but why was the booking fee for birmingham £11 when it was only £7 in manchester, i have long since thought that the NIA and LG arena have been fleecing us, this proves it!!

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    jamie

    I to saw it in Manchester and have to say it truly was the best thing i have ever seen in my life, the graphics, especially during hey you blew me away can’t wait for the announcement that roger will be bringing it around again in 2012

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    Geoff

    I was there last night and it was a truly stunning performance.
    ‘Comfortably Numb’ was the highlight for me!
    Don’t miss this showif it ever comes round again

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    Neil grey

    This show was amazing. Rogers vocals were like hearing the Cd.This show needs to come around again.

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    Darren

    I was there, and its certainly the best show I’ve ever seen which has involved a very large wall.

    Report abuse

  6. 6
    Steve Lewis

    Mr Harrison has recorded a factually correct account of the RW gig.
    It was superb and gives you the assurance that being over 40 and appreciating quality such as The Wall will help you survive the next 10 years worth of X Factor.

    Well done Mr Harrison.
    A bigger well done Mr Waters

    Steve Lewis
    (sanity saved)

    Report abuse

    • Richard Wilkins

      I’ve seen this show twice now, second time at Birmingham, and I couldn’t agree more. As an over 40, subjected to mindless, talentless X Factor tripe, The Wall is a testament to the quality and imagination of truly talented musicians. Although I doubt it will happen, I sincerely hope that Roger brings the show back to the UK next year.

      Report abuse

  7. 7
    havoc

    i saw the show at the o2 in london, blew me away, fantastic.wish the remaining three could get it together and tour once more.here’s hoping

    Report abuse

  8. 8
    Toni

    Was at NIA 27th June. The concert was not all I expected it to be, maybe I’d built it into something bigger in my head.

    Music, ligting, effects etc were really the part. However, the propoganda projected onto the wall showed Waters for the egotistical individual we know him to be.

    Report abuse



Video News From ITN

Entertainment QuickSearch

MoneySupermarket:

Good Loans
APR Comments
Platinum Exclusive
7.2%CHEAPEST Homeowner Loan in the UK for loans from £10,000. <b>Typical APR 15.4%</b>Apply
Sainsbury's Personal Loan
7.2%Nectar card holders receive double Nectar points for 2yrs on £7.5k-£14,999. <b>Typical APR 7.2%</b>Apply
Alliance & Leicester
7.2%For loans of £7,500 - £14,950. Apply online for a quick decision. <b>Typical APR 7.2%</b>Apply
Nationwide
7.3%Loans from £7,000-£14,999. <b>Typical APR 7.3%</b> Discount to Typical APR 7.2% for Flex acc holdersApply
Balance Transfer Cards
Rate Duration Typical APR BT Fee
Barclaycard Platinum
0%17 mths16.9%2.9%Apply
MBNA Balance Transfer Card
0%16 mths16.7%2.88%Apply
Virgin Credit Card
0%16 mths16.8%2.89%Apply
NatWest Platinum
0%16 mths16.9%2.9%Apply

Powered by Moneysupermarket.com

Business Awards

Book a Business Awards table Book a Business Awards table

Join our celebrations of the region's best in business on Thursday March 22 - book your table now

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

entertainment

All the film reviews All the film reviews

Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases

OUR NEW APP

Get the new E&S app Get the new E&S app

Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.