Why we need to save our high streets
Monday 30th May 2011, 9:00AM BST.
I love high street shopping. The thrill of being able to move from shop to shop, picking up treats and bargains along the way from a range of chain stores, department stores and small independent shops, has always been a Saturday afternoon ritual to be cherished writes Emma Iannarilli.
The British high street is an institution that has been part of our shopping culture for a long time – long before the advent of large precincts, retail parks and the Internet.
But this integral part of British life is disappearing and the Midlands is in real danger of losing its traditional high streets.
Look at the evidence. Dudley now has more than 30% of its high street shops empty. Walsall has been blighted by the loss of Woolworths, Evans, Topshop, Miss Selfridge, Next, Topman and Bay Trading from the high street, with the Old Square shopping centre now full of empty shops.
Cannock is another town faced with stores disappearing from its high street. Even the mighty Birmingham has seen many of its stores migrate to the glossy confines of the Bullring.
Our treasured high streets are disappearing fast!
The number one problem facing the high street is the Internet. You can now shop for anything and everything from the comfort of your armchair, avoiding queues, bad weather and parking tickets.
Online prices are often cheaper, with high street stores just unable to compete. But the Internet takes all the fun out of shopping, clicking the ‘Buy’ button can never beat the sheer exhilaration of finding that perfect dress and grabbing the last one in your size, or the fun of a shopping trip with friends, with a coffee and cake break thrown in for good measure.
Out-of-town retail parks are also a growing phenomenon – most Midland towns now have at least one – providing larger branches of favourite stores. These retail parks offer longer shopping hours, often with free parking thrown in and the convenience of stores that carry bigger ranges of goods than your average high street.
But these giant parks encourage companies to desert the high street. Stafford is one town who have lost stores to a retail park, with Mothercare and New Look just two of the companies that have moved to an out of town location.
But not all stores are big enough to move to a vast space on a retail park and many small, independent retailers simply couldn’t afford the rent.
We need our high street to ensure that small businesses and specialist stores don’t just simply disappear in our brave new shopping world.
Think about what we will lose if our high street is allowed to disappear. Independent designers and artisans will have nowhere to sell their wares and charity shops will have to find another way to raise funds.
We need to save our Midlands High Streets, before it is too late.
Emma Iannarilli blogs at fashion-mommy.com. Read her blog here.
Business Awards
Book a Business Awards table
Join our celebrations of the region's best in business on Thursday March 22 - book your table now
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
entertainment
All the film reviews
Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases
OUR NEW APP
Get the new E&S app
Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.
Why save the high street? Is it perhaps a relic of a bygone age?
A relic of a time when people would go shopping two or three times a week while partner was at work, where shopping was carried in bags and no need for a car. And shops were open when you were in town.
These days the shops are open while many of us are at work. The weekend? Why go to the high street on its busy days and walk between shops carrying goods, while clocking up parking charges if you can even park anywhere near your destination?
Out of town can have everything close to where you park, at convenient times. The internet? Order stuff when you are free, have it delivered by the postman or arrange for a time when you know you’ll be in.
And have stuff that hasn’t been endlessly pawed over by everyone….
No, can’t see the high street is of much use. Unless the shops change and the councils provide something to draw people in (free parking and close to shops).
Report abuse
Some good points Martin..but…
1. Many retail parks are now beginning to charge for parking too, and they do not seem to provide enough parking to cater for the amount of visitors using them, hence driving around a carpark for a long time just to find a space (Crown Wharfe, Walsall being an example of both of these problems). Out of town locations are not always well served by public transport which can make these places more difficult to get to for young people and pensioners who don’t have cars.
As for the internet, for those who work this is not always a good option. Most of the time I receive a card put through my door rather than the parcel itself due to post being delivered in the daytime, and then have to fetch it myself anyway. Parcels get lost in the post, things need to be returned, basically nothing is unfallible.
The High Street can provide diversity, choice and can give space to small businesses that cannot afford to operate on those large retail parks.
Report abuse
Well said. I love internet shopping, but mostly because I can never find what I want in town.
Report abuse
Unfortunately, Emma, people are two-faced when it comes to choices and cost. Everyone protests about a new supermarket being built but 6 months after the doors have opened, 90% of the protesters are shopping in there. In my area we had a massive Tesco built under much protest. Look on the car park now and it’s packed out with locals’ cars. They are taking the 40 pieces of silver in the form of 5p a litre off their petrol
That’s the capitalist system mate – winner takes all.
Report abuse
How about drastically reduced rent for those operating on the net, but can’t find suitable space to trade and store their goods? I agree about the high street being an integral part of British life, and maybe this would attract a better class of people back to our town and cities..anything utter than the rats and chavs hanging about the casino’s, fast food outlets and bookies. The focal point of our towns has been swallowed whole, and all we are left with is the fat. Look at places like Great Bridge, West Bromwich and Dudley as a result..they’re in a shocking state, despite some of their landmarks having historical significance. It’s like England and English towns are being wiped off the face of the earth (look at how little even Christmas lights was supported in Dudley). Seems that instead of loving them we fear and loath our towns as we prefer to click buttons on a web page in the comfort of our homes. In the end, I think we lose more than we save, eradicating our sense of community and pride and becoming increasingly complacent as we watch them die.
Report abuse
Yes, I prefer clicking a button. Can spend a couple of hours searching around town for the items I want and only when the shops are open. Or order over the net, at a time convenient for me.
Usually at cheaper prices too.
Just as we don’t miss having the local blacksmith create and sharpen our tools, the local tailor create our clothes, the cooper create our barrels, the candle maker to make our candles, will we miss the high street thats built for a bygone age and opens mostly while we are at work?
Report abuse
This ignores out the people in our society who need the High Street, those who aren’t at work – pensioners, stay at home moms, those without employment..as well as those without computers to do this online shopping. We live in a world where we believe everyone uses computers, but in the Midlands alone there are more than 1 million people who have never accessed the internet (I was on the Joanne Malin programme talking about this very point.)
For many High Street shopping provides a social experience too – a few hours out of the house. As a stay at home mom I cherish a few hours in town with my little boy – a look around, a bit of shopping and then lunch. This gives me a break that internet shopping could never provide.
Report abuse
No mention of Wolverhampton in the above blog, also carrying one of the worst records of unemployment and empty shops!!
From a shoppers point of view cheapest supplier of a product is best?
From a retailers point of view they want low overheads thus in theory increasing the margin or allowing a price reduction against competitors (high st retailer generally) to increase sales, hence win / win.
The high street however will continue to dwindle away with extortionate rates from councils.
High parking costs & wardens round every corner.
The High st needs to move with the times and free parking is a must if they wish to survive long term!
Report abuse
I think this problem is further compounded by our predominant lifestyle..do you see a ‘cafe culture’ in Great Bridge, Tipton? How many places are there to dine, where they don’t see mainly Asian or fast food? Then as mentioned parking, as well as cost of public transport, on some of the most conjested roads in Europe. Add to this some of the longest working hours in Europe..by the time you get ‘down town’ so to speak, half the night’s gone, the shops are closed, there’s nowhere decent to eat and you have to race back because you have to be at work early tomorrow. All that just to look at dirty, boarded-up shops surrounded by chavs and traffic. I don’t think it’s just the Internet that is killing off the high street, I think it’s lifestyles. Sandwell..will it ever change its attitude and adopt the European cafe culture? Don’t hold your breath..
Report abuse
High street shopping has been destroyed by out of town supermarkets and shopping malls
Report abuse
Yes, isn’t it great? Can now do shopping much quicker for what you don’t want off the net, and park for free while doing it. And at convenient times – including picking up food to cook on the way home from work.
Report abuse
I remember when my Gran used to take us kids for a milk-shake at Cooks, in Dudley. Then there was Beatties and it’s comfortable and clean cafe overlooking the town. We sat there with Gran whilst Mom and Dad looked at all the boring stuff (clothes), for which there was no shortage of good-quality produce. If we were good we often had a bag of sweets from Teddy Grey’s and something from Woolworths. Christmas was a great in this town. A few years after this the rot set in. These things might seem mundane, but they bring people together especially the old who live on their own. I accept that in life things must change..but why for the worse? How come other places can retain some sense of civic pride, yet we just end up with places you’d want to avoid? I honestly do not know what the solution is to this decay but it is sad to watch. It’s happening a lot all over the world isn’t it, as we become increasingly globalised. Does it make us happier? Hmm.
Report abuse
I also think that unless you’re ‘clued in’ to technology or at least willing to adopt it, you’re basically part of a lost generation. Look at the incredible growth of high-speed Internet, and lately mobile hardware that means you’re never far away from finding the cheapest deals even before you leave your house. All you know is that somewhere some nameless entity is probably working their rear off to supply you with what you want, when you want it. The whole marketing and distribution environment has changed so drastically and so quickly that the effects are obvious in what we see in places like Wolverhampton, Dudley and similar towns that are still trying to compete with bricks and mortar. Kids will grow up now knowing nothing of this, and it does make me wonder whether they will grow up with the right attitudes towards fair play: wages, working conditions etc, or whether they will be too obsessed with their electronic ‘toys’ to notice. To those controlling these markets and their associated hardware, the profits must be incredible. For those refusing to adopt this technology, the consequences are self-evident. Can there be a compromise in the form of high-street shopping?
Report abuse
Just wondering what will happen to our fab independent stores in this brave new shopping world? Stores like Teddy Greys, Mr Simms sweet shoppe, Wisteria Lane, White Stuff etc wouldn’t be big enough to survive on a retail park- will we end up losing all our small shops? What about the Charity shops that do a vital job raising funds – I’m sure they won’t be offered a peppercorn rent on retail parks – what happens to them.
I worry we will have a lot less choice -the internet is great, but many of thewebsites are from already established High Street stores. Will new stores be able to compete on the net if the High Street goes. Companies like ASOS and BooHoo do well, but heavily advertise in women’s magazines – new and small companies simply wouldn’t be able to afford to do this.
We could end up with a lot less than we started with.
Report abuse
An interesting article and an aspirational stance.
As a Nation, we have followed the American Retail Model and are therefore paying the ‘Social’ price for its inevitable and arguably unstoppable journey.
There is a great Docu Film that was released several years ago… it still holds true Today.
‘Wal-Mart The High Cost of A Low Price’
Essential viewing for anyone with a real interest in this Subject
Report abuse
Not everyone has internet access or necessarily wants to do shopping on the internet. I use the internet for certain goods (DVDs and items I can’t source locally), but I enjoy the experience of physically walking into a shop, browsing the goods, interacting with folk. I like finishing off with a pint of ale in a traditional pub – that social interaction that cannot exist in the same way on the internet.
The high street is part of English tradition & culture, is often in the very centre of a city, town or village. It is the point of convergence for a whole area & should remain as such as it always has been – the social centre or heart of a community.
The high street should retain a place alongside the internet (over reliance on technology is never the best option) and retail parks, effort should be made to lower rent cost and / or parking costs to get shops open & people shopping there.
Report abuse