Proof you should never go back
Tuesday 25th January 2011, 11:23AM GMT.
They say, whoever they may be, that you should never try to replicate former glories, writes our Grumpy Old Man Bill McCarthy.
There is no better demonstratio of this than in the case of ancient DJ Simon Bates getting the morning slot on Smooth Radio.
I know Smooth targets people of a certain age, but dinosaurs like Bates should be consigned to the Natural History Museum, along with the other fossils. I feel like a spring chicken in comparison.
It was bad enough listening to him back in the eighties, but at least then you didn’t have to put up with the insufferable adverts as well.
Smooth used to be an easy listening locally-based radio station that has decided to go national and has suffered as a result.
Not only is Bates back, he is now asking listeners whether the appalling Our Tune, the mawkish slot he presented on Radio 1 a liftetime ago, should return with him.
Hence the point about former glories. Our Tune was anything but glorious This nauseating drivel allowed saddos to whine on endlessly in public, through the sanctimonious Bates, about their failings, illnesses or sheer awfulness of their lives.
All of this with the dreary Romeo and Juliet film music in the background had me reaching for the painkillers.
Now, after listening to Smooth, formerly Saga for a few years now, the hiring of Bates, and other Radio 1 relics like Mark Goodier and Andy Peebles has me reaching for the ‘off’ button or even in desperation, tuning in Chris Evans on Radio 2, or even, God help us, Chris Moyles on Radio 1.
No, it really is that bad.
*****
Neighbours from hell must be a terrible thing, but what about the ones who are just plain irritating.
You know the kind, they never do enough for a full-blown row, but just chip away at your senses until you are seething.
They leave bin bags and garden rubbish more outside your place than theirs; despite having a drive wider than the M6, they still manage to park close enough so they have to get out of the car on your grass.
Then they reverse off the drive over your grass, or cut the corner coming returning leaving tyre tracks.
Gormless and living in a world of their own or just selfish idiots?
*****
It must be galling for hard-pressed motorists feeling the squeeze on petrol prices to hear the genius the transport secretary Philip Hammond blaming the looming price rise on ‘the mess left by Labour.’ Fair enough, Labour’s love of taxing fuel is well documented.
But excuse me. Just who is in government now and has the power to overturn it?
Go figure, as our American pals would say.
Business Awards
Book a Business Awards table
Join our celebrations of the region's best in business on Thursday March 22 - book your table now
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
entertainment
All the film reviews
Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases
OUR NEW APP
Get the new E&S app
Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.
Hi Bill,
Just wanted to say that your blog and that of your colleague Peter Rhodes brighten up my day no end!
Greetings from Hannover, Germany.
Michael
Report abuse
I have grown up with Simon Bates when he used to be on radio 1. Listening to Simon still brings back a lot of memories from when I was a teenager growing up. I always remember getting ready for school and hearing Simon Bates on the radio; was a pleasure to listen to even though Simon has moved to Smooth FM recently. Up and untill this day I am listening to Sir Simon Bates every morning before I go to work and I must say he is still my number 1 DJ.
Report abuse
Bev, this must meen you skived off school as he was on mid-mornings :-)
Report abuse
Bates is terrific! what a shame some talenless second rate hack has sharpened his pencil with utter rubbish. Who is he anyway . never heard of him! Smotth is on all through our work shop and is the best breakfast radio since Sir Tel went!!
Report abuse
Everything has it’s own era of time Simon Bates is an old Radio 1 DJ from the 80′s,Smooth have now gone national and hired him,I have nothing personally against him but please don’t bring back that “Our Tune Drivel”
it’s time to move on now,some new blood/fresh faces are what’s needed now.Simon I’m sure you could spend your retirement in your garden!Jimmy Saville was better on a Sunday dinner time with his “Old Record Club”
I know I’m sad,never mind work to be done in the garden! Watching the grass grow!
Report abuse
I have to say I agree with you wholly regarding the Transport Minister. The sooner the Tories stop whining on about inheriting Labour problems and get on with the job in hand the better. -0.5% economic growth in the last quarter of last year would suggest they should stop blaming others and pull their own fingers out, or is that Labour’s fault too?
Report abuse
PT, then don’t tune in? Why don’t you try Radio 3 as that should sound nice in the garden. We love it and stop working for a tea break to listen to Our Tune. It sounds like you have a story so why not send it in. Is it a grumpy one?
Report abuse
Simon Bates was extremely popular on Radio 1 with some excellent features in his show. The fact he’s doing breakfast shows radio says something about his durability.
He has a great broadcasting voice and is very skilled. Let’s face it, Smooth breakfast is a better gig than say Beacon Radio?
Report abuse
Don’t think the ConDems have yet made it compulory to listen to Smooth radio? So just turn over… try Radio 4 occasionally when everything else gets infuriating.
Worst thing about radio for me is that modern car radios are hopeless on Medium and Long wave and the BBC won’t put the cricket (R4 Long wave) and football (Radio Five Live and 5 Live extra) on FM because they want us all to buy DAB sets.
Report abuse
If Andy Gray can be (and rightly so) sacked, for sexist remarks, then surely it’s time you were given YOUR marching orders for seriously abusive, ageist remarks aimed at discrediting Simon Bates. I realise that you are only being controversial, aiming to provoke reader response so it is in this vein, along with your own egotistical self promotion that you do so, but I still fail to see why you should get away with calling Bates a ‘dinosaur’ that ‘should be consigned to the Natural History Museum’. I AM a Smooth listener – at least while driving, and I’m certainly not a dinosaur, but the station suits me and the era I came out of. I was never a Simon Bates fan, but his return to the air and the reintroduction of ‘our tune’ which you describe as ‘mawkish’ evokes memories and if takes listeners from the ever present relentless pressures of life to a little bit of nostalgic escapeism, then what’s the harm in that? Provocation, but at what price? Don’t feelings count for anything these days? Remarks as serious and detrimental as calling someone a Dinosaur that should be consigned to the Natural History Museum, and being paid for it. I think not.
Report abuse