Sherlock Holmes: Doctor Who in waiting?

Monday 26th July 2010, 6:55AM BST.

Sherlock Holmes: Doctor Who in waiting?

Benedict Cumberbatch will make a brilliant 12th Doctor Who, writes Dan Wainwright.

Were it not for the lack of TARDIS and attractive female companion I could easily have believed I had accidentally tripped my vortex manipulator and been watching the Time Lord’s adventures in 2012 while Sherlock was on.

It is believed that Matt Smith is going to hang up the tweed and realise bow ties are not cool at the end of the next series.

So there’s no harm in wondering who will take on the biggest job in prime time television when that happens.

Cumberbatch, at 34, is about the age David Tennant was when he caught the wandering eye of Russell T Davies and was cast in Casanova. That series essentially became his audition tape to become the Last of the Time Lords.

Now Steven Moffat, at the helm of Doctor Who, has rebooted Sherlock Holmes minus the deerstalker and opium addiction and could well be using it to test out his new leading man.

With Mark Gatiss involved as well, lending more than just one script or guest appearance this time, the links between 221B Baker Street and Gallifrey are clear to see.

Cumberbatch himself is rakish, looks well in a long coat and has the ability to switch from moody to arrogant to verbally incontinent with ease. In short, he’s already playing The Doctor – “Is it nice not being me? It must be so relaxing” – is dialogue that was probably left over from Doctor Who.

Not that this should take away anything from the best bit of Sunday night TV that I can remember in a long time. Sherlock stands up to scrutiny in its own right for a clever script with plenty of clues that no-one can get but that are obviously there when you know the answer.

The nicotine patches in place of opium and pipes were a brilliant touch and the camp malevolence of Gatiss left no doubt that this was intended to be a bit of fun and escapism – and there’s nothing wrong with that.

It’s just a shame it’s been scheduled for the height of summer when its viewing figures will be far short of what it truly deserves. If the remainder of the series keeps up the plot and acting to this standard then we’re in for a treat.

The game is afoot. Or, rather “on”, as these modern types say nowadays.


  1. 1
    Cherry Cola

    When David Tennant left Doctor Who I was actually rooting for Ben Cumberbatch to take over, having seen him in many excellent dramas. He’s been one of my favourite actors for a long time. I was bitterly disappointed when Matt Smith took over. Now, having seen Who 11 in action I happily admit to underestimating Smith, he’s done an excellent job. BUT I still secretly yearn for a Cumberbatch Doctor next time. Sherlock is wonderful, more than enough to tide me over…

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    Darren Browne

    As a fan of the original books and the Jerermy Brett interpretation I sat down to watch and fully expected pick this latest incarnation to bits. However, within 15 minutes I was not even questioning that Cumberbatch was Sherlock. It is different from the original but remains very much Sherlock Holmes. Note:Sherlock was not addicted to any drug but did use Cocaine (not opium) recreationaly and where as I love the Doctor and recognise the similarities its worth noting that Sherlock was about 100 year before the Doctor and will probably outlive him by soem considerable way as well. The charcter is in no way an audition.

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    derry667

    Honestly, I think it’s unlikely at this stage.

    I love Benedict Cumberbatch as Sherlock and I loved him as Pitt the Younger too. But if Moffatt is still at the helm when Matt Smith leaves (and I’m hoping the 11th Doctor will be around for a few years yet), the I wouldn’t be surprised if the 12th Doctor is another “complete unknown”. I think Moffat understands the value of bringing in a “dark horse” to upset the audience (and critics) expectations.

    Anyway, it’s my understanding that Matt Smith tried out for the part of Watson before he even auditioned for the Doctor and that Cumberbatch had already been cast as Holmes. So, if Moffat had wanted Benedict Cumberbatch to play the Doctor (and assuming the actor wanted to play the role), why did he not cast him in the role back then?

    I wouldn’t be surprised (and would be very pleased) if Benedict Cumberbatch does appear on Doctor Who in another role though. There’s plenty of room for gifted actors to play the Doctor’s allies (David Morrissey and Arthur Darvill, for that matter) or enemies (Derek Jacobi and John Simm).

    Speculation is always fun, but with Moffat casting the role, I think you have to think outside (probably way, WAY outside) the box.

    Report abuse



Business Awards

Book a Business Awards table Book a Business Awards table

Join our celebrations of the region's best in business on Thursday March 22 - book your table now

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

entertainment

All the film reviews All the film reviews

Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases

OUR NEW APP

Get the new E&S app Get the new E&S app

Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.